Upload
Do we always need to be threatened?
Loading ...
While driving, we can either respect the rules of the road, or not. But we always respect them when we know a cop is watching us, or when we know a photo radar system has been installed. These are intimidating forces that ensure we comply. But is that the only way we'll behave? Is the threat of punishment the only thing that will improve our attitude behind the wheel?
Replies
A couple of months ago, the city of Montreal placed about 150 photo radars around the city. Since then, I have to say I've never seen so many cautious drivers in my life. However, I quickly noticed people are cautious at certain points, only. Going to work every morning, I can't help but laugh at how everyone races (about 60-70 km/h) to the point where the photo radar is clearly marked. Then, we all slow down (about 30 km/h) for half a block to pass the booby trap. Once we are sure that the radar can no longer see us, everyone guns it downhill. Although I'm not proud of racing to work every morning, the experience shows that threatening people with fines definitely works. Maybe there are just not enough photo radars out there.
Okay, threatening people with fines does work. But sometimes I think the city cares more about the money it makes than about protecting people on the road. I wouldn't mind more photo radar systems if the city takes it easy with the parking tickets. Something has got to give. Show us this is not just another money grab.
Although I agree with Stanspert, I have to add that the issue is not black and white, of course. Punishment for wrongs committed against society has existed since man has walked the earth. In primitive societies punishment was carried out by individuals wronged, or by their families. It was more vindictive in nature, but it also served as an example for all. Everyone who found out got a sense of what the repercussions for an offense could be. The threat of punishment keeps us savage animals at bay. Now, is the city abusing their power to impose fines? Yes, I think it probably is. But if drivers were not threatened with punishment, the roads would be hell.